🧐How to Spot a Fake Wine Enthusiast

In the plush tasting rooms or at dinners where wine flows freely (and sometimes recklessly), there’s a growing species: the fake wine enthusiast. You know the type, talks like a sommelier straight out of Hogwarts but still confuses Bordeaux with Burgundy on the map.

This article lists 7 classic profiles of such impostors, but beware: sometimes they are all seven rolled into one, like a chaotic, grape-stomping hydra. It’s time to lift the veil on this vinous charade, with elegance, humor, and just the right amount of cheekiness (as any good wine chat should).

Profile 1: The Vocabulary Virtuoso (Or the Walking Wine Dictionary… But Not Really)

Meet the fake wine enthusiast who thinks that sounding impressive means dropping complicated words like “retroactive oxidation” or “mineral phenolics” every five seconds. They will confidently tell you that the wine is “very tannic and fruity”, forgetting that tannins don’t exactly scream “fruit salad.” Or they might claim they can “taste the sulfites,” which, spoiler alert, is more myth than reality.

In truth, this profile is a master of verbal pyrotechnics without substance. Their strategy? Use jargon as smoke and mirrors, hoping no one calls their bluff. But the giveaway is always the awkward mismatch between their fancy words and the actual sensory experience.

If you catch someone tossing around technical terms like confetti but failing to describe the wine in simple, honest terms, you might be in the presence of our Vocabulary Virtuoso.

Profile 2: The Grand Cru Groupie (or “If It’s Not Famous, It’s Not Worthy”)

Here’s the fake enthusiast who worships only the legendary names: Château Margaux, Romanée-Conti, Petrus, you name it. For them, wine is less about taste and more about brand flexing. They will drop these names in conversation like a seasoned sommelier… without ever having tasted them, or worse, without knowing what makes them special.

Ask them to explain the history or the characteristics of these Grand Crus, and suddenly, their impressive wine lingo fades into vague mumbling. Because really, they are collecting reputation points, not tasting notes.

Meanwhile, a true wine lover knows gems exist at all price points and regions, from lesser-known appellations to humble but delicious wines. But the Grand Cru Groupie? They only salute the big names, and scoff at anything less famous as if it were grape juice from the bargain bin.

If this charming individual swears by Château Margaux, Petrus, or Romanée-Conti, without ever describing what’s actually in the glass, be wary. For them, wine is a luxury accessory, not a taste experience. They collect labels like some collect Swiss watches, except here, it’s all for show.

Pro tip: Mention a lesser-known appellation like Pic-Saint-Loup and watch the confusion spread.

Profile 3: The Curiousness-Deficient (a.k.a. The Wine Explorer… Not)

True wine lovers are like kids in a candy store, eager to discover new regions, grape varieties, and styles. But our fake enthusiast? Their curiosity is as dormant as a cork in a sealed bottle. They stick religiously to the “big names” and familiar labels, avoiding anything unfamiliar like it’s a wine with a spider in the bottle.

Offer them a bottle from an obscure appellation or an unexpected vintage, and they will dismiss it with a raised eyebrow or a polite, noncommittal “meh.” Because stepping outside their comfort zone is apparently more terrifying than trying a bold new red with seafood.

If you want to spot this profile, watch for someone who treats wine exploration like a chore rather than an adventure.

Profile 4: The Price-Is-Right Philosopher (or “If It’s Expensive, It Must Be Divine”)

This enthusiast has swallowed the myth that the price tag is the ultimate marker of quality. To them, a costly bottle automatically means greatness, no questions asked. They will sniff a 150 euros wine with reverence and dismiss a 15 euros gem as “probably not worth the trouble.”

But here’s the truth: expensive doesn’t always mean exceptional, especially if you are drinking it from a plastic cup while scrolling on your phone. Conversely, some affordable wines punch well above their weight, delivering surprising complexity and joy.

The real connoisseur knows that wine is about intrinsic qualities, not just digits on a price tag. So, if you notice someone obsessing over price more than flavor, you have likely found yourself face-to-face with the Price-Is-Right Philosopher.

Profile 5: The Flavor Vagueness Champion (a.k.a. The “It’s Good” Expert)

Ask them what the wine tastes like, and their response will likely be: “It’s good,” or “It’s strong,” followed by a hopeful smile. Specific notes? Aromas? Structure? Texture? Nope. Nada. Zilch.

A genuine wine lover, even without fancy vocabulary, can describe the wine’s acidity, finish, or maybe a hint of cherry or oak. Our Flavor Vagueness Champion? They are stuck in a world of vague adjectives and sweeping generalities, like trying to describe a Monet by saying “it’s colorful.”

This inability to articulate flavors is a dead giveaway that the person’s tasting experience is surface-level at best.

Profile 6: The Image Over Substance Enthusiast (or “Look but Don’t Taste”)

Meet the wine fan whose passion seems to end at the bottle’s label, and the perfect Instagram shot. They will parade around with an expensive vintage like it’s a designer handbag, snapping photos from every angle but barely lifting the glass to their lips.

For them, wine is more a status symbol than a sensory delight. They are experts in brand names and bottle aesthetics but novices when it comes to tasting notes or sharing genuine experiences. Conversation usually revolves around the price, rarity, or the clever cork design, not the flavors, the mouthfeel, or the story behind the wine.

If you find someone more focused on flexing their cellar than savoring a pour, congratulations, you have found the Image Over Substance Enthusiast.

Profile 7: The Food and Wine Pairing Amateur (or “What Goes with What? Who Cares?”)

One of the greatest joys of wine is how it dances with food, like a perfectly choreographed pas de deux on your palate. But the fake enthusiast? They couldn’t care less. Red wine with oysters? Sweet white with steak? They throw together mismatched combos like a toddler mixing paint colors, blissfully unaware of the culinary chaos they’re creating.

True wine lovers understand that pairing enhances both the food and the wine, elevating the whole experience. The amateur? They are too busy showing off their wine knowledge to notice their disastrous dinner decisions.

If you hear someone recommending a bold Cabernet with delicate sushi or a sugary dessert wine with spicy chili, you’re witnessing the Food and Wine Pairing Amateur in action.

The Real Deal vs. The Pretenders🍷😄

Detecting a fake wine enthusiast isn’t rocket science, it’s more like noticing a cork that just won’t pop right. These seven profiles, whether they appear one by one or all at once like a bewildering wine cocktail, reveal a simple truth: true wine lovers are humble, curious, and passionate. They savor the experience, delight in discovery, and share their joy without pretense.

The fake enthusiast? They are often more focused on impressing than tasting, more about image than substance, and less about adventure than comfort zones. Next time you’re swirling, sniffing, or sipping, remember that wine is a conversation, between the glass, the palate, and the soul.

So raise your glass to genuine passion, honest curiosity, and maybe, just maybe, a little less jargon at the table.

Cheers to sipping with style, and a splash of good humor!

---

Discover More

Sources:

Smith, B. C. (2007). The Taste of Wine: The Art and Science of Wine Appreciation. Wiley-Blackwell.

Charters, S., & Pettigrew, S. (2007). "The dimensions of wine quality". Food Quality and Preference, 18(7), 997-1007.

Goldstein, R., Almenberg, J., Dreber, A., Emerson, J. W., Herschkowitsch, A., & Katz, J. (2008). "Do More Expensive Wines Taste Better? Evidence from a Large Sample of Blind Tastings". Journal of Wine Economics, 3(1), 1-9.

Harrington, R. J. (2007). Food and Wine Pairing: A Sensory Experience. Wiley.